Once again, shocked onlookers painted from familiar palettes as they described the latest young man to march into the public square with his guns blazing.
The alleged killer was a moody, quiet loner who excelled at school. He was a normal guy who loved movies and super-hero tales, only he cheered for the villains. When hanging out in bars, he was usually sitting alone.
Journalists also quoted people who knew the family and said that James Holmes was once, as The Los Angeles Times noted, "heavily involved in their local Presbyterian church" in San Diego.
You see, even a kid from a normal church can evolve into someone who dyes his hair red, buys 6,000 rounds of ammo, girds himself in a full body-armor suit and, when surrendering to Aurora, Colo., police, identifies himself as the Joker, the incarnation of postmodern evil.
"What does 'Presbyterian' mean in this context?" asked Aly Colon, a nationally known journalism ethics consultant. "It's like no one really stopped to ask if there was there something about this particular label -- the actual content of this word -- that connected in any way to this event.
"Does this kind of label give readers anything to stand on? ... It's like these words are hovering up in the sky, with no connection to the facts on the ground," he said.
Truth is, in Southern California, "Presbyterian" can describe everything from evangelical megachurches to oldline Protestant congregations on the religious left.
So was the Holmes family active in the liberal Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) or the conservative Presbyterian Church in America? How about the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, the Evangelical Presbyterian Church, the Bible Presbyterian Synod, the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church, the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America or the American Presbyterian Church?