PLATTSBURGH -- City councilors strongly rejected a plan to make traffic on the U.S. Oval one way instead of two-way.

Councilors voted 5 to 1 against the change, citing the impact it would have on the surrounding area and the potential to increase hazards rather than decrease them.

"I don't think we've thought through the risks clearly enough to warrant a change," Councilor Amy Valentine (D-Ward 5) said.

The proposed change was to make one lane on the Oval for motor vehicles, with the inside lane for non-motorized travel.

The one-way traffic most likely would have traveled in a counter-clockwise direction.

Residents on both sides of the issue spoke to councilors for about 30 minutes before the vote was taken Thursday night.

Oval resident Luke Cyphers, a supporter of the change, noted that the area is zoned specifically for recreational uses.

"It is in the spirit of the zoning to make this available and easy for recreation," Cyphers said.

"That's what it is supposed to be."

Cyphers' wife, Lisa Cyphers, said making the oval one-way with a recreation lane would enhance the area for the entire region.

"People are drawn to the Oval because it's a great place for recreation," she said.

"I would like to see it as a special place not just for us, but for the whole region."

Mrs. Cyphers noted that residents of the Oval would actually be the most inconvenienced by the change, but would put up with it in exchange for the benefits.

Other supporters said the nearby bicycle path along the lake is too remote and not safe for children to travel alone, and the oval would be more appropriate for biking, walking and in-line skating.

But not everyone was convinced the change would be a good idea.