WXPort
Sponsored by: Plattsburgh Area Weather Sponsored by CVPH Medical Center

Resources

print this story   Print this story
email this story   E-mail this story
  Post to del.icio.us

Photos


Brenda Rabideau
P-R File Photo /

Published May 11, 2009 11:03 pm - Brenda Rabideau did not take the stand after a defense expert testified she suffered from "extreme emotional disturbance" when she shot her husband.

Defense rests in attempted-murder trial
Psychiatrist cites 'extreme emotional disturbance,' Rabideau defense rests

By ANDREA VanVALKENBURG
Staff Writer

CHARGES

Brenda Rabideau is facing charges of second-degree attempted murder, first-degree attempted assault, second-degree assault, first-degree criminal use of a firearm and first-degree reckless endangerment.

PLATTSBURGH — In late April 2008, less than two months after Brenda Rabideau shot her husband, a forensic psychiatrist found she was suffering from "extreme emotional disturbance."

"I believe that she did lose control of herself based on her extreme emotional disturbance," Dr. Jonathan Weker testified Monday during the Ellenburg Depot woman's attempted-murder trial.

The defense-hired expert from Vermont took the stand Monday morning before Clinton County Family Court and Integrated Domestic Violence Court Judge Timothy Lawliss and told the 14 jurors how he came to that conclusion.

Based on State Police reports, transcripts of Rabideau's taped conversation with police minutes after the shooting and interviews with the 50-year-old mother of four, Weker felt Rabideau lost control of herself when she shot Ricky Rabideau in the back with a .22-caliber rifle.

He said her increasing life stressors, coupled with her ongoing cancer diagnosis and history of "major depression" and anxiety, caused her to suffer the extreme emotional condition, which is the basis for her criminal defense.

Weker also felt she suffered significant "harassment and certainly emotional neglect" during her failed 20-year marriage to the 46-year-old contractor.

The defense is not disputing that Mrs. Rabideau shot her estranged husband outside their former Mooers Forks home after an argument about his new relationship and divorce appraisals.

Mrs. Rabideau had been treated for depression and panic disorders for several years before the shooting and was briefly hospitalized in a psychiatric unit around the time she filed for divorce.

Stephen Johnston, who is Rabideau's attorney, questioned Weker in detail. Then Assistant District Attorney Timothy Blatchley delved into Weker's experience reviewing emotional-disturbance cases and his familiarity with New York laws.

During the cross-examination, Weker said he found "no indication" that Rabideau intended to kill her husband, which is a component of the second-degree attempted-murder charge against her.

He later admitted that her actions demonstrated the "ability to reason."

Before the defense rested its case, Mrs. Rabideau's mental-health counselor, Kathy Sajor, said her client "had been under enormous stress" during the months before the shooting.

While on the stand Monday afternoon, she classified Mr. Rabideau's past treatment of his wife as "cruel."

Guided by Blatchley's questioning, Sajor later admitted that it's not uncommon for people to experience a "cluster of negative emotions" during failed relationships.

Champlain EMS emergency-medical technician Alison Poupore later told the jury that Mrs. Rabideau did not appear to be under the influence of controlled substances immediately after the shooting.

Mrs. Rabideau was heard in a taped conversation with police saying she was suicidal and had consumed an entire bottle of anti-anxiety medications, which subsequent testing apparently failed to detect.

Despite "no outward signs" of an overdose, Poupore said, "she appeared distraught" and said "I don't care if I live or die."

Mrs. Rabideau did not take the stand in her own defense.

So far, jurors have heard from a dozen prosecution and seven defense witnesses.

The trial is expected to resume this morning, when the prosecution calls two rebuttal witnesses, including another psychological expert, who is expected to testify against the emotional-disturbance defense.

Closing arguments may take place as soon as this afternoon.

E-mail Andrea VanValkenburg at: avanvalkenburg@pressrepublican.com



print this story    email this story   




ADVERTISEMENT



Premier Guide
How to Contact Us

MAIN OFFICE
Press-Republican

P.O. Box 459
170 Margaret Street
Plattsburgh, NY 12901
(518) 561-2300


NEWSROOM
Hours:
Weekdays 8 a.m. to midnight; Weekends, 2 p.m. to midnight
Phone: 518-565-4131 Fax: 518-561-3362
E-mail: news@pressrepublican.com
Sports: 518-565-4124
Features: 518-565-4138


CIRCULATION/CUSTOMER SERVICE
Hours:
Weekdays 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., Saturday and Sunday (phone only) 8 a.m. to noon.
Circulation Phone: 518-565-4110


CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING
Hours:
Monday - Friday, 8am to 5pm
Phone: 518-565-4105 Fax: 518-561-1172
E-mail: classifieds@pressrepublican.com
Obituaries & Legals: 518-565-4178
Obituary E-mails: obits@pressrepublican.com
Legal Ad E-mails: legalads@pressrepublican.com

Today's Front Page
View P-R Frontpage:   Click on the image of the Press-Republican frontpage to view our frontpage archives.

Subscribe:  Click here to receive a subscription to the Press-Republican for as little as $13.00 per month.

Frontpage Reprints:  Click here to purchase a reproduction of a full page of the Press-Republican.
Today's Front Page
SITE INDEX
NEWS:  Local NewsPolice, Fire CourtsBusinessMoney & MarketsEducationEnvironmentOutdoorsPolitics & ElectionsBirthsEngagementsWeddingsAnniversariesProperty TransfersLookbackWeather
SPORTS:  Local SportsHigh SchoolCollegeYouth & AdultSports ShortsOutdoorsFishingFlashbackToday's Sports Events
OPINION:  EditorialsCheers & JeersIn My OpinionLettersSpeakoutColumnsBlogs
ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT:  Out & AboutMovie ReviewsEntertainment NewsCelebrity NewsLotteriesCrosswordsSudokuHoroscopes
LIFESTYLES:  PeopleHome & GardenHealthSeniorsFaith & SpiritualityFamily
OBITUARIES:  Current obituaries & search past yearObituaries archiveGuestbooksObituary submission guidelines
PHOTOS, ETC.:  Featured galleriesRecent newspaper photosBonus SportsCommunity EventsFull Page ReprintsAudio Slide ShowsVideoWebcams
SEARCH ARCHIVES:  Past 7 Days2007 - Present1999 - 2007Very Old Archives (Historic Newspapers)
LIVING HERE:  Clinton Co.Essex Co.Franklin Co.Day Away
MARKETPLACE:  ClassifiedsLegal Ads Find a jobFind a carBuy a Classified adFree CouponsAdvertiser Index
ABOUT US:  Contact usAdvertising Information 
© 2009, CNHI

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.