Press-Republican

Clermont

June 11, 2011

Reporting on youth crimes

The death of Karen Bourdon on May 1, allegedly at the hands of her 14-year-old son, raised a number of ethical questions in our newsroom.

When people have asked, over the years, what the hardest part of my job is, the answer has always been: Dealing with all the ethical issues that come up.

Almost every week, something difficult needs to be decided. Do we publish an unusual arrest even though it is a misdemeanor and we normally report only felonies? Do we allow an anonymous source in a story? Should a certain story run on Page 1 or an inside page?

There are no easy answers for most of these types of questions. We try to think about our responsibility to inform the community, our sensitivity to the people affected by news, our past history of dealing with a similar issue.

The Bourdon murder raised several tricky questions. Obviously, a murder is major news and must be reported. But this one involved a young teen, Dilan Clark.

Reporting on crimes by youths is always difficult. We are well aware that the record of their arrests and any conviction will stay with them for life.

We also know their brains are not fully formed, as has been confirmed in a number of studies, and therefore they aren't always at the top of their game when making decisions about risky behavior.

A violent crime perpetrated by a child is rare around here, the most notorious being the stabbing of 10-year-old Andrew Pitkin by Michael Murphy, his 14-year-old neighbor in Valcour, back in April 1984. Murphy is now 40 and still in prison. It is a story we have returned to many times as he goes before the Parole Board.

When we report on a teen involved in a high-profile crime, we will be criticized no matter how we play the story. Some people don't think it should even be in the paper.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Clermont
  • lois_clermont.jpg The rush on Election Day

    We thought Barack Obama or Mitt Romney would mess us up Tuesday night, but it was actually Bill Owens who did, Editor Lois Clermont writes.

    November 8, 2012 1 Photo

  • lois_clermont.jpg Editing Speakout is challenging

    Speakout is overwhelmingly popular, emphasis on overwhelming, Editor Lois Clermont writes.

    April 21, 2012 1 Photo

  • lois_clermont.jpg First Box isn't about winning a race

    The Internet has put local media outlets in a competitive situation, but accuracy still must be more important than speed, Editor Lois Clermont writes.

    January 2, 2012 1 Photo

  • lois_clermont.jpg Never without a book

    I remember the magical feeling when, as a kid, I had saved up enough money for a new book and got to go to the back of Marie Beemer's stationery store on Brinkerhoff Street to make my selection, Editor Lois Clermont says.

    August 1, 2011 1 Photo

  • lois_clermont.jpg Reporting on youth crimes

    The death of Karen Bourdon on May 1, allegedly at the hands of her 14-year-old son, raised a number of ethical questions in our newsroom.

    June 11, 2011 1 Photo

  • lois_clermont.jpg Misconceptions about the Press-Republican

    Everyone has their pet peeves at work. Over the years, I have heard a few generalizations about the Press-Republican that are frustrating, Editor Lois Clermont writes.

    May 2, 2011 1 Photo

  • Column: Decisions made more difficult by Internet

    One of the many difficult decisions we have to make at the Press-Republican is when to publish the name of someone who dies in an accident or fire, explains editor Lois Clermont.

    March 19, 2011

  • Screening letters, by the numbers

    One of the jobs I am getting used to in my new role of editor is monitoring letters sent to the Press-Republican. It's not as easy as it might seem.

    February 15, 2011