WXPort
Sponsored by: Plattsburgh Area Weather Sponsored by CVPH Medical Center

Published October 10, 2009 09:37 pm - Dysfunction, complacency won't get us back on the road to prosperity.

Repairing economy calls for bold moves


COLIN READ, Everybody's Business

Certainly there are few places quite like New York State.

This is a state where politicians and political-action groups consider politics a full-contact sport. The irony is that New York had historically been a state of innovation and inspiration. Now it seems to be mired in a state of paralysis.

Perhaps political dysfunction is proportional to the stakes in the game. After all, the federal government often takes the bud of good economic policy and runs it through the political sausage maker. By the time it is done, we somehow manage to create less effective policy that rewards the power brokers or the status quo.

For instance, this month we celebrate the annual anniversary of the most significant stock market decline in our history. While stocks have rebounded somewhat from the 50 percent decline, we are still more than 25 percent down. Even the market after the Great Crash of 1929 was all but recovered a year later, only to plunge once again as a consequence of protectionism and bank failures.

We are also nearing the second anniversary of our recession, placing it as the longest recession since the Great Depression.

By this point, I would have hoped for more.

A couple examples demonstrate less than effective monetary and fiscal policy.

The mammoth stimulus bill has, by almost all measures, failed to stimulate the economy to date, even if it has at least prevented the economy from getting worse.

This failure is primarily the result of poor execution. To date, only about 40 percent of the stimulus money has been spent. The federal government ultimately relied too much on the states to direct the spending transfers. Unfortunately, the parties of some states like ours were too busy suing each other to offer effective economic leadership in these critical times. Instead, states used the federal windfall to delay the day of fiscal reckoning. Ultimately, few jobs were created, and instead, the money was used to prevent layoffs, necessary or not.

Meanwhile, some political-action groups continue to ratchet up the rhetoric to protect their lot. Some even used fear tactics that hearken back to the days of Willie Horton and Lee Atwater. I recall last summer's ads that tried to avert layoffs of prison workers by asserting that any cutbacks to prison budgets would unleash terror as violent prisoners are thrust into society.

The government is also wrestling with providing effective and affordable health care. The maneuverings to secure the necessary votes seem destined to ensure the result is neither effective in insuring the uninsured, nor affordable. Many experts agree that the most necessary element of a health care package is cost containment. With a baby-boomer population that is aging, and with the vast majority of health-care costs concentrated in post retirement years, a failure to contain medical costs will cause future federal deficits to spin out of control.

While the din of political rhetoric is scary, the economic consequence of these political failures is scarier yet.

Democracy fails when it devolves to a system where nothing gets done unless everybody is happy. A coalition of those concerned, on the left and the right, can, and typically does, band together to ensure nothing changes. One group may believe change is too rapid, and the other not rapid enough. The antics of both groups ultimately preserve the status quo, no matter how unfortunate it is.

In an economic or business environment that can ill afford the status quo, our penchant for democracy and inclusiveness holds us back. It is obvious that business as usual can get us in to some terrible messes. And business as usual causes us to be mired in this current mess for far too long.

Our economic commander in chief has, unfortunately for us all, become mired in such dysfunction. His economic intuition is good, but his faith in Congress has been his and our Achilles heel. He has been unwilling to make the bold moves a declining economy requires.

Perhaps our economic commander in chief fears using up his political capital too early in his tenure. He, or his advisers, seems to view life in terms of political capital. One would hope we live in a meritocracy that replenishes political capital through success. But if the vast majority of those who benefit from bold leadership are silent, while the minority of those unwilling to change are most vocal, political capital is destroyed rather than created.

Even in this state of heightened dysfunction, the economy appears to be repairing itself. We will probably discover in about six months that this quarter marked the end of the Great Recession. Technically, we define a recession's end when we begin to pull out of our downward spiral. It will take much longer for the economy to return to normal. It will likely be many quarters or years before the economy returns to 4 percent unemployment, a recovered stock market and sustained economic growth of between 2 and 3 percent.

Given that little economic reform has occurred in the last year, it may take years to finally see real reform. The intervening quarters and years may finally offer Congress an opportunity to make the changes necessary. Unfortunately, time also allows opposition to mount, and somehow makes familiar the pain we are currently experiencing.

With this familiarity comes comfort with a new status quo. Just like frogs that remain comfortable in a pot of water that slowly moves from lukewarm to boiling, we become increasingly complacent as we become accustomed to terrible.

Wouldn't it be nice if we could aspire for better and expect more? And wouldn't it be nice if our economic leaders accept their calling on our behalf? Call me naive, but guiding us to a better future is what I thought leadership was all about. I will try to suspend my disbelief, and trust that, somehow, economic reform will emerge from this Congress.

Colin Read is the former dean and now teaches economics and finance in the School of Business and Economics at SUNY Plattsburgh. His fourth book, "The Fear Factor," has recently been published by MacMillan Palgrave. He also runs an economic and business consulting company, and can be reached at economicinsights@gmail.com.



print this story    email this story   




ADVERTISEMENT



Premier Guide
How to Contact Us

MAIN OFFICE
Press-Republican

P.O. Box 459
170 Margaret Street
Plattsburgh, NY 12901
(518) 561-2300


NEWSROOM
Hours:
Weekdays 8 a.m. to midnight; Weekends, 2 p.m. to midnight
Phone: 518-565-4131 Fax: 518-561-3362
E-mail: news@pressrepublican.com
Sports: 518-565-4124
Features: 518-565-4138


CIRCULATION/CUSTOMER SERVICE
Hours:
Weekdays 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., Saturday and Sunday (phone only) 8 a.m. to noon.
Circulation Phone: 518-565-4110


CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING
Hours:
Monday - Friday, 8am to 5pm
Phone: 518-565-4105 Fax: 518-561-1172
E-mail: classifieds@pressrepublican.com
Obituaries & Legals: 518-565-4178
Obituary E-mails: obits@pressrepublican.com
Legal Ad E-mails: legalads@pressrepublican.com

Today's Front Page
View P-R Frontpage:   Click on the image of the Press-Republican frontpage to view our frontpage archives.

Subscribe:  Click here to receive a subscription to the Press-Republican for as little as $13.00 per month.

Frontpage Reprints:  Click here to purchase a reproduction of a full page of the Press-Republican.
Today's Front Page
SITE INDEX
NEWS:  Local NewsPolice, Fire CourtsBusinessMoney & MarketsEducationEnvironmentOutdoorsPolitics & ElectionsBirthsEngagementsWeddingsAnniversariesProperty TransfersLookbackWeather
SPORTS:  Local SportsHigh SchoolCollegeYouth & AdultSports ShortsOutdoorsFishingFlashbackToday's Sports Events
OPINION:  EditorialsCheers & JeersIn My OpinionLettersSpeakoutColumnsBlogs
ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT:  Out & AboutMovie ReviewsEntertainment NewsCelebrity NewsLotteriesCrosswordsSudokuHoroscopes
LIFESTYLES:  PeopleHome & GardenHealthSeniorsFaith & SpiritualityFamily
OBITUARIES:  Current obituaries & search past yearObituaries archiveGuestbooksObituary submission guidelines
PHOTOS, ETC.:  Featured galleriesRecent newspaper photosBonus SportsCommunity EventsFull Page ReprintsAudio Slide ShowsVideoWebcams
SEARCH ARCHIVES:  Past 7 Days2007 - Present1999 - 2007Very Old Archives (Historic Newspapers)
LIVING HERE:  Clinton Co.Essex Co.Franklin Co.Day Away
MARKETPLACE:  ClassifiedsLegal Ads Find a jobFind a carBuy a Classified adFree CouponsAdvertiser Index
ABOUT US:  Contact usAdvertising Information 
© 2009, CNHI

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.