Press-Republican

Opinion

October 17, 2013

Editorial: Amtrak numbers on the upswing

This is a source of disagreement around the nation, but we firmly believe Amtrak is carrying a significant burden in Americans’ need to get from here to there.

In the fiscal year ending Sept. 30, Amtrak set records for number of riders and ticket revenues received. A total of 31.6 million travelers took the train in 2013, including 11.4 million in the Northeast Corridor, which includes us. (It also includes Washington, D.C., Philadelphia, New York City and Boston, which accounts for the impressive volume.)

That’s the second-best figure recorded in that sector in Amtrak’s 41 years of operation. So why are the critics so relentless?

Amtrak is subsidized, as are all forms of transportation in American, including cars. The federal government contributes billions in highway funds every year.

Amtrak maintains that it pays 85 percent of its bills from ticket sales and other revenues, leaving about 15 percent for the government. Still, the per-ticket subsidy for Amtrak is acknowledged to be higher than other forms of transportation.

But Amtrak fills a need that no other form of transportation could fill, except one — the automobile.

Just imagine what our streets and highways would be like, especially through Washington, Philadelphia, New York and Boston, if those 31.6 million riders were forced to use automobile transit. Amtrak is fulfilling a vital service by keeping them off the roads.

And this is in spite of some admittedly lax service. If you’ve ever ridden the Adirondack train that runs between Montreal and New York, through Plattsburgh, you know the train is late more often than it should be. Why that reliability factor can’t be improved upon remains a mystery.

In England, for example, if you arrive at your station one minute late to catch your train, you almost certainly missed it. Departure and arrival times are strictly adhered to. Keeping on schedule can be done.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Editorial

Cheers and Jeers

Letters to the Editor
Speakout
In My Opinion

Recent Columns