Politics and Elections

September 11, 2013

Malone party-petition changes probed

MALONE — A special prosecutor and the State Board of Elections are investigating possible petition tampering in Franklin County.

Clinton County District Attorney Andrew Wylie was named special prosecutor in the case involving alleged changes to Democratic Party petitions filed with the County Board of Elections.

The petitions are allegedly associated with the party caucus and County Democratic Committee nominations held in the Town of Malone on July 22.


On that date, petitions for those wishing to be named to the party’s committee were circulated.

The Town of Malone has 10 districts, and two people are selected from each to serve not only on the party’s town committee but the County Democratic Committee.

Those seeking a committee seat must file petitions and obtain signatures from at least 5 percent of the eligible party voters in their own election district.

Signatures obtained from voters living in a different election district do not count toward that 5 percent threshold.


The petitions are filed with the County Board of Elections. It is up to the person who circulates the petition, not the election commissioners, to verify that the signatures are actually from eligible voters in his or her election district.

Once filed with the county, there is a three-day window for anyone to file an objection to a petition. Any objector then has six more days to specify what signatures may be invalid.

After that, election commissioners would hold a hearing to weigh the complaint and make their ruling. If a signature is deemed invalid, it is removed from the nominating petition.

Anyone can request a copy of a nominating petition once it is filed with the Board of Elections and becomes public record.


An unnamed person made such a request for nominating petitions that Town Councilor Mary Scharf carried for other committee candidates, but the request came after the three-day objection period expired. One petition sought signatures for committee nominations for Hugh Hill and Jean Pond and the other for Donald Merrick and Deborah Merrick.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Politics and Elections
CVPH Job Opportunities
Videos: Campaign 2012
Man Has No Regrets Over Romney Face Tattoo Most Voters Support Eliminating the Electoral College Work starts on inauguration stage for Obama's 2nd term Mitt Romney's President-elect website unveiled by accident The Game Pays For New Yorkers To Vote Republicans were simply 'wrong': Gingrich Best Memes for Election Day 2012 Dow Falls More Than 300 Points After Election Best-Worst Celebrity Tweets During Election 2012 Same-sex marriage measure leads in vote count Obama victory leads to celebration in the streets Obama: "We Are One American Family" Romney: "I ran for office because I'm concerned about America" Romney: "We can't risk partisan bickering" Romney HQ Reacts To Obama Win Paul Ryan Re-elected as Representative In Wisconsin Obama HQ Goes Wild During Iowa Returns