January 27, 2014

Next steps in NYCO land swap questioned

RAY BROOK — The plan for NYCO Minerals to test mine on state land has been called into question by environmental groups.

Proposition 5, approved by voters statewide last November, allowed a constitutional amendment granting the Willsboro-based mining company access to wollastonite deposits on state land adjoining its mine in the Town of Lewis.

Proposition 5 also approved a swap of 1,500 acres of NYCO land for the 200-acre parcel of state land.

The next step in NYCO’s proposal is to dig test mines to see if enough of the mineral is on the property, called Lot 8.

But how that effort proceeds is the subject of a letter sent by Earthjustice to the State Department of Environmental Conservation.

The 13-page letter represents the concerns of several preservation groups, including Adirondack Wild, Protect the Adirondacks, the Sierra Club’s Atlantic Chapter and the Atlantic States Legal Foundation.


At Adirondack Wild, founding partner David Gibson said Earthjustice is an environmental law firm.

He did not say that legal posturing in the letter is precursory to a lawsuit.

“That’s not the subject of this letter,” Gibson said.

But the letter gives DEC 15 days to respond to numerous questions about how NYCO test mining would be brought into compliance with legal language in the Adirondack Park State Land Master Plan; with DEC’s Jay Wilderness Unit Management Plan; and with DEC’s Temporary Revocable Permits policy for state lands and easements.

The 15 days are not legally binding, Gibson said.

“That’s just businesslike. We could have given them 30 days; we just picked 15 days,” he said.


The gist of the legal pursuit suggests, in the letter’s conclusion, that the passage of Proposition 5 “removed only one layer of legal protection for Lot 8 and only for expressly specified purposes. 

“Because no enabling legislation has been passed to implement the amendment of (the Forever Wild constitutional clause), minerals sampling operations may not proceed on Lot 8, and Lot 8 may not be exchanged for other land, until, at a minimum, the Legislature passes new (laws).”

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Colin Read's Column

Business Spotlight
Peter Hagar's Farm Column

Farm Briefs
Videos: Business News
After Fukushima, Japan Eyes Solar Power New York Auto Show Highlights Latest in Car Tech New York Auto Show Highlights Latest in Car Tech High-flying Tech Stocks a Concern for Investors "Heartbleed" Bug Puts Internet Security at Risk AP Tech Review: Samsung Galaxy S5 Toyota Recalls 1.8M Vehicles in the US Comcast Executive: 'Merger Not a Problem' Microsoft Ends Support for Windows XP Study: Airline Industry Complaints Drop in 2013 Study: Airline Industry Complaints Drop in 2013 Employers Add 192K Jobs; Rate Stays at 6.7 Pct Senators Press Barra About GM's Delay in Recall More Americans See Middle Class Status Slipping GM CEO Faces House Hearing on Recall NHTSA: GM Should 'Fix Vehicles Quickly' GM's CEO Testifies on Faulty Ignition Switches Owner, Families Share Cobalt Stories Jury Selection Begins in Apple-Samsung Case BMW Plans $1 Billion Expansion in South Carolina