NORTH ELBA — Last week's McCulley decision has stirred interest over what's next for Old Mountain Road.
After years of lawsuits, Department of Environmental Conservation Commissioner Pete Grannis ruled the route through the wilderness is a town road, never formally closed or abandoned.
Grannis dismissed DEC enforcement action against Jim McCulley, who drove a snowmobile onto the road seven years ago and was ticketed for using a motorized vehicle on state land.
But, environmentalists are not pleased with the decision.
ROUTE TO CLOSURE
The Adirondack Council is demanding that Grannis implement a little-used Highway Law 212 and "undo damage" that the environmental group says the McCulley decision portends.
"Commissioner Grannis has the authority to use (Highway Law 212) to prohibit the use of motorized vehicles on this and other roads that are affected by this decision," Adirondack Council Executive Director Brian Houseal said in a statement.
"We urge Commissioner Grannis to begin that process right away."
But legislation was already being sought to amend Highway Law 212.
Bills introduced in January by Sen. Betty Little (R-Queensbury), and Assemblywoman Teresa Sayward (R-Willsboro) would "remove the ability of the state to modify, abandon or close roads within the Adirondack Park," saying road closure by the state "disrupts local transportation without compensation to the local community."
The legislation is currently in Transportation Committees of both houses.
USE IS RARE
Transcripts from McCulley's Essex County case show Highway Law 211 originally applied to roads on state lands used "for farm or prison purposes."
An amendment in 1929 removed that restriction and also removed the need for notice to the towns.
Attorney Matthew Norfolk, McCulley's counsel in the Old Mountain Road case, finds only four cases since 1977 where the law has been used, besides McCulley.
"DEC has previously looked to use Highway Law 212 to close roads on Forest Preserve land 'if the land on both sides of the road is state land and the road terminates on state land'. That's been DEC's stated position," Norfolk said.
Old Mountain Road does not end on state land in the two towns it traverses: North Elba and Keene.
"This may explain why, despite repeated requests from the Adirondack Council in the past, DEC has not, and most likely will not, attempt a Highway Law 212 closure of Old Mountain Road," Norfolk said.
North Elba Town Supervisor Roby Politi said after the Grannis decision that "as far we're concerned, Old Mountain Road has always been a town road."
He sees the McCulley decision as an opportunity for towns to co-create a unique recreation corridor.
"It would be nice if both towns agreed on what the corridor could be used for."
Politi called the Adirondack Council's call for closure "fighting words."
Keene Town Supervisor Bill Ferebee couldn't be reached for comment.
Ken Jubin, who owns land at the North Elba end of Old Mountain Road, said "it's great" that DEC finally recognized the route as a public highway.
"This means that the Town of North Elba and the Town of Keene have a width of 66 feet to use (according to historic laws); there's plenty of room for whatever recreational purpose that each of these towns desire to create."
Reacting to the council's call for closure, Jubin said the potential loss could be too great.
"The Old Mountain Road has too much potential use for the towns. The outdoor enthusiasts are definitely a component of the tourist trade here, for everyone — ice climbers, hikers, cyclists, snowmobilers and skiers."
As a passageway through the forest, Old Mountain Road has been maintained by the Adirondack Ski Touring Council for decades as part of the Jackrabbit Ski Trail.
Tony Goodwin, president of the Adirondack Ski Touring Council, said Old Mountain Road should remain a non-motorized trail. His group has maintained the passage since the 1980s.
"I definitely do not think that it would be possible to make that into a good snowmobile trail and certainly not a trail wide enough to accommodate both skiers and snowmobiles. There are sections too narrow for more than one snowmobile at a time."
Goodman believes Grannis should close it under Highway Law 212.
"But it would remain a trail. The one piece of the puzzle left is to relinquish any sense that this is a town road."
E-mail Kim Smith Dedam at: email@example.com
- Breaking News
Moriah fire victim died of asphyxiation
The manner of Sierra A. Daha's death remained under investigation, police said.
- Moriah fire victim died of asphyxiation
- New Today
Port Kent 4-year-old suffers from epilepsy
Brodie Sussdorff's mom, Angie, hopes to network with other families with children who have the condition.
- Port Kent 4-year-old suffers from epilepsy
- Local News
Woman found dead in gutted home
The fire that destroyed the residence in Moriah Center is suspicious, police say.
Sierra Daha remembered fondly
Friends say the young woman, whose body was discovered after a fire on Tuesday, was a sweet person who wanted to help others.
City OKs nursing home expansion
Site-plan approval still needed as Meadowbrook Healthcare looks to go from 200 beds to 287.
Franklin County wins $3.5 million grant
Emergency-services funding will upgrade radio equipment and replace some existing communications towers with taller ones.
Clinton County legislators seek budget input
Public hearing on proposed spending plan for 2014 will be held tonight.
Grease fire damages Tupper apartment
No other units were affected at the Ivy Terrance complex.
Old-fashioned Christmas marks Maille home
Barbara Maille continues to collect decorations as inspiration gives her new ideas.
Santa popular at Plattsburgh home
Sherman and Jackie Luck have continued to expand their Christmas display since 1965.
Northeastern Clinton Central Middle School Honor Roll
Here is the Northeastern Clinton Central Middle School Honor Roll for the first quarter
Of Interest: Dec. 4, 2013
Take a brief look at news of note from around the North Country.
- December 3, 2013
Beekmantown unions switch to Plan B
Beekmantown Central School Teachers and Support Staff associations have agreed to switch to the less costly health-insurance coverage, a move expected to save the district more than 18 percent annually in premiums.
Arrest made in connection with city fires
Bruce Bombard, 17, charged with arson.
Essex County overrides tax cap
With a 15 percent tax hike looming in the new budget, Essex County lawmakers voted to surpass a 2 percent state tax cap.
Malone may get revolving loan
An eight-year-old grant request resurfaces and could bring the town $1.3 million in no-interest funding to create a third water district.
Essex County still stalled on radios
Essex County lawmakers now want to hear directly from the manufacturer before awarding a mobile-radio installation contract.
CCC, Potsdam ink new pact
Agreement allows Clinton Community students to easily transfer to SUNY Potsdam.
National conference focuses on college readiness
Local students, educators participate in College for Every Student event.
- Woman found dead in gutted home